Are Illegal Immigrants Causing the U.S. Measles Outbreak? What the Data Shows

Are Illegal Immigrants Causing the U.S. Measles Outbreak? What the Data Shows

TL;DR: No. The data does not support blaming illegal immigration for America’s measles surge. Of the 5,838 confirmed cases this year, 96% were in people who were unvaccinated or whose status was unknown. The largest outbreaks hit rural, close-knit American communities with low vaccination rates, and those places barely overlap with where undocumented immigrants live. Migrant shelters and detention centers have had real outbreaks, but they account for a small share of the total.

On November 17, 2026, the Pan American Health Organization ruled that the United States has lost its measles elimination status. The country had held that status since 2000. Mexico and Bolivia lost theirs the same day. Canada lost its status in 2025.

The numbers explain the ruling. As of November 19, the CDC had counted 5,838 confirmed measles cases in 2026. That is more than double the 2025 total of 2,289, which was already the highest count since 1991. The CDC lists six deaths this year, and state health departments report more.

As the case count climbed, a familiar explanation spread: illegal immigration brought measles back. It’s a reasonable question to ask. Measles travels with people, and people cross borders. So we checked the explanation against the record. We looked at who is getting sick, where the outbreaks are, and where undocumented immigrants actually live.

The Claim

The most prominent version of the claim came on August 23, 2026. Rep. Byron Donalds (R-Fla.) told CBS’s Face the Nation that measles outbreaks were caused by “rampant illegal immigration” under the previous administration. Asked for evidence, he pointed to outbreaks in El Paso, Texas, and Southwest Florida. His office did not respond to questions from FactCheck.org.

The idea has surface logic. Some migrants come from countries where childhood vaccination rates have fallen. Shelters and detention centers are crowded, and measles spreads fast in crowded places.

That gives us a testable prediction. If immigration were driving the surge, cases should cluster where immigrants are. They don’t.

Who Is Actually Getting Measles

Start with vaccination status. According to the CDC:

  • 96% of 2026 cases were unvaccinated or of unknown status
  • 2% had one MMR dose
  • 2% had both doses

The CDC does not record a patient’s immigration status. It does record where the infection came from. This year, 96% of cases are tied to outbreaks inside the country. Only 18 cases were international visitors.

Imported cases have also become a shrinking share of the total. FactCheck.org found that imports made up 41% of U.S. cases from 2001 to 2011. In early 2025 they were about 6%. Most of those imports were not foreigners at all. The CDC reported that 92% of imported cases in early 2025 involved U.S. residents coming home from trips abroad.

The simplest way to think about it is spark and fuel. A traveler supplies the spark. An unvaccinated community supplies the fuel. Sparks have always come and gone. What changed is how much fuel is lying around.

Where the Hotspots Are vs. Where Undocumented Immigrants Live

Pew Research Center estimated a record 14 million unauthorized immigrants in the U.S. in 2023. About 56% of them lived in six states, according to Pew’s state breakdown.

Here is how those six states line up against this year’s biggest measles hotspots.

RankMost undocumented immigrants (Pew, 2023)Largest 2026 measles hotspots
1California (2.3 million)Pennsylvania
2Texas (2.1 million)South Carolina
3Florida (1.6 million)Utah
4New York (825,000)Wisconsin
5New Jersey (600,000)Ohio
6Illinois (550,000)Texas

Only Texas appears on both lists, and most of its outbreak happened in 2025. California has the largest undocumented population in the country and is not a major hotspot. New Jersey and Illinois aren’t either.

The timing doesn’t line up either. Pew says the unauthorized population probably began shrinking in 2025 because of increased deportations. Measles cases more than doubled anyway. In Infection Control Today, physician Kevin Kavanagh made the same point: illegal immigration has been falling while measles has been rising.

Older data agrees. A Cato Institute analysis of state data from 2010 to 2018 found no connection between a state’s immigrant share and its measles rate. Cato is a libertarian think tank that generally favors immigration, so some readers will discount it. Its finding still matches the current case data.

What Happened in the Biggest Outbreaks

West Texas

The 2025 outbreak began in Gaines County, a rural area with a large Mennonite community. In the Seminole school district, about 82% of kindergartners had their measles shots in the 2023-24 school year. About 17% of the county’s kindergartners filed vaccine exemptions.

Texas lawmakers asked the state’s top health official directly whether illegal immigration caused the outbreak. Dr. Jennifer Shuford told them, “We don’t know what the link is.” PolitiFact found the outbreak started among Texas residents who had not traveled internationally. Two unvaccinated school-aged children in Texas died that year.

Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania is the center of the 2026 surge. By October 9 the state had confirmed 1,136 cases, and 99% of the patients were unvaccinated. Lancaster County accounted for 415 cases and Mifflin County for 167.

Lancaster County is home to one of the country’s largest Amish and Plain communities. According to a 2025 estimate, only about a quarter of the local Amish population had been vaccinated against measles. In August the state recorded its first measles deaths in 35 years.

Southwest Florida

Representative Donalds cited Southwest Florida, but the outbreak there started at Ave Maria University, a private Catholic school in Collier County. The county reported 107 cases from January through April. The university’s dean said Florida’s health department believed the most likely source was a student who had traveled to another state over the holidays.

Mexico

In this case the virus went south. Mexican health officials traced Chihuahua’s outbreak to a 9-year-old Mennonite boy who had visited relatives in Seminole, Texas. He came home sick and the virus spread through his school. Mexico has since confirmed more than 17,000 infections.

Where the Immigration Argument Has a Point

Immigration-linked outbreaks do happen, and a fair fact-check has to say so.

Detention centers. Hudspeth County, Texas, reported 136 cases, and the state said all of them were in federal detention. Those facilities hold a mix of inmates, and the patients’ immigration status hasn’t been confirmed. Smaller clusters hit ICE facilities in El Paso (14 cases), Florence, Arizona (7 cases), and Dilley, Texas (2 cases). Suppose every one of the Hudspeth cases involved an undocumented immigrant. That would still be about 2% of this year’s national total.

The Chicago shelter. In 2024, a measles outbreak at a Chicago migrant shelter infected 57 people. Most residents were recent arrivals from Venezuela, where routine childhood vaccination had declined. The city ran a mass vaccination campaign, and the outbreak stayed contained.

Staff matter too. In 2016, an outbreak at the Eloy Detention Center in Arizona was spread partly by guards who refused vaccination. When the 2026 cases appeared in Arizona facilities, Pinal County health officials reported no community spread.

One more detail tends to get lost. Legal immigrants have to be vaccinated against measles. Tourists and Americans returning from overseas trips do not.

The lesson from these cases is about settings, not nationality. When unvaccinated people are packed together, measles moves fast. That makes detention conditions a real public health issue, but they are a small part of the national picture.

The Vaccination Gap Is the Real Story

The CDC’s numbers are blunt. MMR coverage among kindergartners fell from 95.2% in the 2019-20 school year to 92.4% in 2025-26. That leaves roughly 280,000 kindergartners unprotected.

The national figure also hides the real risk. Measles needs about 95% coverage in a community to stay contained. A 2026 study in Nature Medicine found that outbreak locations ranked in the top tenth for risk when measured school by school and district by district. A state can look fine on average while individual schools sit far below the threshold.

Some of the decline is logistical. Pandemic-era disruptions led to missed appointments that were never made up. Some of it is a choice: nonmedical exemptions have risen, and communities with shared religious or personal objections to vaccines cluster together.

Does Politics Play a Role?

Partly, and the trend started earlier than many people assume. A Stanford study of electronic health records covering 1988 to 2024 found a widening partisan gap in childhood vaccine refusal. Republican parents became steadily more likely than Democratic parents to refuse vaccines. The gap began growing around 2000, well before COVID.

Polling shows the same split. In a 2025 KFF survey, about three in ten Republican-leaning parents said they lacked confidence in the safety of the MMR vaccine.

Party alone doesn’t explain where outbreaks happen, though. The 2018-2019 outbreaks hit Orthodox Jewish communities in New York and New Jersey, in some of the most Democratic states in the country. What the major outbreaks have in common is a tight-knit community with low vaccination coverage.

Where RFK Jr. Fits In

Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. spent decades as one of the country’s best-known critics of vaccines, including the MMR shot, before he took over HHS in 2025. His record on measles since then is a matter of public record.

Treatment messaging. During the 2025 Texas outbreak, Kennedy promoted vitamin A and cod liver oil. He wrote that vitamin A “can dramatically reduce measles mortality.” The World Health Organization does recommend vitamin A for people who already have measles. It does not prevent infection. The American Academy of Pediatrics warned that relying on vitamin A instead of the vaccine puts children at serious risk.

Vaccination as a “personal choice.” Kennedy has publicly encouraged measles vaccination while also calling it a personal decision. Public health experts have argued that mixed message weakens the push to vaccinate.

Policy changes. In June 2025, Kennedy removed every member of the CDC’s vaccine advisory committee and appointed replacements, including members who had openly criticized U.S. vaccine policy. In January 2026, HHS cut the childhood schedule from 17 universally recommended diseases to 11, without the committee’s usual review. MMR stayed on the universal list. Most physician groups and many states rejected the new schedule. The Infectious Diseases Society of America called it “reckless.”

His defense. At an April 2026 hearing, Kennedy said, “I have never been anti-vaccine.” He pointed out that Canada and several European countries have also lost their elimination status, and he has blamed COVID-era disruptions to routine vaccination. After the PAHO ruling, he pledged on X to “stop measles outbreaks, protect American families, and work to regain U.S. measles elimination status.” CDC Director Erica Schwartz put it more directly: “The measles elimination designation is not what protects Americans. Vaccination does.”

Part of Kennedy’s defense is accurate. Vaccine coverage began slipping around 2020, before he took office. Critics respond that the worst outbreaks in 35 years happened on his watch, while the person running federal health policy was sending mixed signals about the one tool that stops the virus. Readers can weigh that record for themselves.

Follow the Coverage, Not the Border

Measles needs two things to spread: someone to bring it in and enough unprotected people to pass it around. The first will never go away, because people travel. The second is where the U.S. lost ground.

The evidence points in one direction. The biggest outbreaks started in American communities with low vaccination rates, and some traced back to Americans returning from trips. The virus crossed from Texas into Mexico, not the other way around. Migrant settings have produced outbreaks, and they should be taken seriously. They are still a small share of the cases.

Blaming the border is a comfortable story. The data shows the problem is local vaccination coverage.

Key Takeaways

  • 96% of the 5,838 confirmed U.S. measles cases in 2026 were in people who were unvaccinated or whose vaccination status was unknown.
  • Only 18 cases this year were international visitors. Most imported cases come from Americans returning from trips abroad.
  • The biggest hotspots, including Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Utah and West Texas, are rural communities with low vaccination rates. They are not where most undocumented immigrants live.
  • Detention centers and a 2024 Chicago migrant shelter had real outbreaks, but they make up a small slice of the national total.
  • Kindergarten MMR coverage fell from 95.2% to 92.4% in six years, and outbreaks spread in local pockets far below the 95% threshold.
  • The 2025 West Texas outbreak traveled south and seeded Mexico’s much larger epidemic.
  • A partisan gap in vaccine refusal has been widening since about 2000, but low coverage in tight-knit communities predicts outbreaks better than party does.
  • Two MMR doses are about 97% effective, and they remain the best protection against measles.